top of page

If you're selling lab-grown diamonds, make integrity a priority.

Aug 7, 2025
3 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

This article was originally published in INSTORE Magazine on August 8, 2025. Read the original here.


Few topics are as divisive or as misunderstood within the jewelry industry as lab-grown diamonds. But it is a conversation that deserves more honesty, more foresight, and far more caution.


Lab-grown diamonds are marketed as innovative, ethical, and accessible. But under the surface, they carry significant long-term risks for both retailers and customers, risks that tend to get glossed over. It’s time we talk about them.


Let’s talk about value.


In 2021, a 2-carat lab-grown diamond retailed for approximately $6,000 to $8,000. Today, similar stones are retailing for around $1,200 to $1,500, a drop of more than 75% in just four years.¹ Meanwhile, some Chinese suppliers are producing lab-grown diamonds for as little as $2.10 to $3.80 per carat.² That means retailers charging thousands are selling a product with a production cost comparable to a fast-food combo meal.


Is lab-grown creating trust issues?


This collapse is not just a pricing issue; it’s a trust issue. A client who bought a lab-grown engagement ring in 2021 may return expecting to upgrade, only to find their $8,000 purchase is now worth less than $500.³ Unlike natural diamonds, which many independent retailers back with generous trade-in programs, lab-grown stones typically offer zero resale or upgrade value. The emotional fallout from that realization can break client relationships for good.


Some argue, “If the customer wants a lab, give them a lab.” But as professionals, we owe them transparency. If you choose to carry lab-grown, make your policies crystal clear. Note on the receipt that resale and trade-in value are not guaranteed. Let your customer make an informed choice, and don’t depend on your sales team to do all the educating.


Beware of the upgrade pipeline drying out.


Equally concerning is how lab-grown diamonds are displayed. Putting a $1,284 lab stone next to a $17,000 natural invites a race to the bottom.⁴ Eighty percent of customers, when shown similar-looking stones, will opt for the cheaper one.⁵ Without context, you’re training your customer to see natural diamonds as overpriced rather than enduring.


Let’s not forget the broader business model implications. A natural diamond sale might yield a lower margin (40–50%), but it’s more likely to bring in a higher ticket and a return customer.⁶ Selling lab-grown at a 70% margin doesn’t mean much if your average ticket falls and your upgrade pipeline dries up. Big box stores brands can make the math work through sheer volume. Some have thousands of locations or unlimited digital reach. While most independents are operating from a single storefront, where every transaction matters exponentially more.


The “don’ts” of lab-grown sales.


There may be a place for lab-grown diamonds, but only with guardrails. Don’t put them in the same case as natural. Don’t oversell their long-term worth. Don’t confuse access with value. And most of all, don’t lose a client’s trust over a short-term sale.


The “do’s” of responsible selling.


Double down on natural diamonds’ legacy. Promote your trade-in programs and long-term upgrade benefits. Elevate storytelling around rarity, generational value, and emotional investment. If you must sell lab-grown, lead with education, not promotion. Be proactive, not reactive. Protect the relationship first. Because in this business, that’s the only thing that truly lasts. Repeat business depends on trust, not transactions.


This industry is built on emotion, trust, and legacy. Lab-grown diamonds, for all their hype, offer none of those unless we create that clarity ourselves.


Sources:


Rapaport Diamond Research, May 2025 Market Report


South China Morning Post, "Lab Diamond Production Costs Plummet," March 2025


JCK Online, “The Trade-In Trap: Why Lab Diamonds Undermine Retail Loyalty,” April 2024


Brilliant Earth Price Comparison, June 2025


GIA Lab-Grown vs. Natural Consumer Behavior Study, 2023


Bain & Company, “Global Diamond Industry Report,” 2024


 
 
 

Comments


CONNECT ON LINKEDIN 

            @MEGANCRABTREE

  • LinkedIn

© 2021 CRABTREE CONSULTING. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

bottom of page